Blog
The Peel region, including Brampton, has seen a significant rise in mental health issues in recent years, prompting suggestions from local government officials, including the mayor, for mandated treatments. This proposal has stirred debate among both the community and mental health professionals. To fully understand the implications, we must consider the statistics reflecting the mental health landscape in Brampton and Peel.
The alarming increase in mental health problems, evidenced by local health data, has prompted Brampton officials to consider strong measures to address the situation. Mandated treatment is viewed by some as a necessary response to severe cases, reducing emergency service burdens and improving public safety, while others are concerned by the potential harms to individuals who would be mandated. Critics argue that providing more access for treatment as well as addressing psychosocial contributing factors to mental health and addictions is a better approach.
According to data from Peel Public Health, there has been a notable surge in emergency department visits due to mental health disorders and addictions in Brampton. The trend is particularly strong among young adults, while related issues like behavioral disorders, substance abuse, and domestic violence have also escalated (1).
Rising Emergency Visits: Examining rates of emergency room visits can be an important marker of changes in the mental health landscape. Since 2010, urgent care visits to Brampton’s mental health and addictions emergency department have increased by 121 percent. (2)
Youth Impact: The rate of emergency department visits for those younger than 14 years old has doubled as has the rate of emergency room visits for youths aged 15 to 24 years old. Many youths in Peel are also experiencing a moderate to high level of distress (49% for females and 30% for males). (3)
Substance Use Concerns: In the Peel region, there have been 705 substance use related deaths in the last five years (2) and a report from the Region of Peel in 2017 noted that opioid related deaths have now surpassed the rate of deaths associated with motor-vehicle accidents (1)
Socioeconomic Factors: Economic challenges such as high living costs and job insecurity contribute to mental health issues. Many residents in Peel confront financial stress, a known risk factor for mental illness.
Given the dire statistics, mandated treatment has been proposed as a strategy to manage the increasing mental health crises effectively. The proponents of mandatory mental health treatment tout the following as justification for moving in this direction:
Immediate Support: Mandated treatment may provide immediate care for individuals in acute mental health crises, potentially preventing tragic outcomes. Current waitlists for treatment, particularly publicly funded services for severe mental health issues can be extensive or limited.
System Relief: With mental health-related emergency visits on the rise, mandated treatment could help manage ongoing care outside hospitals, easing system burdens. About 30,000 calls to the police since 2022 have been related to mental health and substance use issues (2).
Preventive Measure: Could early and mandatory intervention prevent some individuals’ mental health conditions from worsening? Some argue that this could be the case which would have broader social and economic benefits.
There are also many that object to mental health treatment being mandated and for them, they state the following concerns:
Personal Autonomy: There are significant ethical concerns regarding personal autonomy and the right to consent, which are fundamental human rights issues (4). Furthermore, if the treatment is viewed by the patient as coercive and forced, they may be less inclined to engage.
Social Stigma: Mandated treatment could reinforce negative stereotypes about mental illness and deter individuals from seeking voluntary help due to fear of forced intervention.
Variable Outcomes: Research has yet to show conclusively that mandated treatment leads to better long-term mental health outcomes. The length and nature of the treatment is also an importance consideration as well as patient choice in type of treatment/provider.
The recommendation by Brampton’s mayor for mandated treatment is a response to the mounting mental health emergencies in the city. While according to proponents, they say this approach might offer immediate benefits and relief to health services, but as those who object point out, it can also pose significant ethical challenges and effectiveness concerns. Discussions around mandated treatment for criminal offenders and offering more voluntary treatment resources have been offered as suggestions in this debate. As discussions continue, addressing the mental health crisis in Peel requires a considered approach that respects individual rights and promotes long-term well-being, grounded in evidence and compassion.
References
1) https://www.peelregion.ca/health/reports/_media/pdf/opioids-in-peel.pdf
—
Staying informed about contemporary issues related to mental health and therapy is important to us at the Momenta Clinic. We applaud discussions such as the above and the mayor of Brampton’s acknowledgement of the severity of Peel (and Brampton’s) mental health and addiction concerns. We also support taking a careful approach to decisions regarding mandated treatment, consulting with the literature, individuals and relevant stakeholders. Any decision involving potential risks to individuals, potential infringement of one’s rights as well as treatment effectiveness are important considerations.
The Momenta Clinic is distinguished by its team of seasoned Brampton psychologists and therapists who specialize in a wide array of treatments, including trauma therapy, depression therapy, and advanced online therapy options for Ontario residents. We are committed to providing personalized, evidence-based care. Whether you’re seeking support for anxiety recovery, exploring online therapy from Toronto, or looking for compassionate, expert-led depression therapy in Brampton, Momenta Clinic is your sanctuary for healing and growth.
In an era where mental health care is more vital than ever, Momenta Clinic stands as a testament to the power of professional intervention and compassionate care. Allow us to be your partner in navigating the journey towards recovery and empowerment, one step at a time.
© 2024 Momenta Clinic. Psychological Assessment and Therapy in Brampton, Toronto and Virtual Sessions in Ontario.
Terms of Use, Privacy and Cookie Policy,
Toronto: